Boston Cream Pie, Parker House Rolls and the Story of a Famous Hotel

Two classic comfort foods were born in the same downtown Boston hotel. Here is the history behind Boston cream pie and Parker House rolls.

Fresh bread rolls on a white cloth

Some foods carry a city’s name around the world. Boston cream pie is one of them, and it shares its birthplace with another classic, the Parker House roll. Both trace their roots to a single downtown hotel that has been feeding Bostonians since the 1850s.

The Parker House

Harvey Parker opened the Parker House on School Street in 1855, across from where Boston Latin School once stood and near the Old City Hall. It quickly became one of the city’s leading hotels, known for fine dining and an elegant setting. Today it operates as the Omni Parker House and is often described as the longest continuously operating hotel in the United States.

In the 1800s, the hotel’s dining rooms hosted an informal literary group known as the Saturday Club. Members included figures such as Ralph Waldo Emerson, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr. and Nathaniel Hawthorne. Charles Dickens also stayed at the hotel during a visit to America.

Advertisement

A pie that is really a cake

Boston cream pie was created at the Parker House in the 1850s. Despite the name, it is a cake: two layers of sponge cake filled with pastry cream and topped with chocolate glaze. At the time, the line between pies and cakes was blurrier than it is now, and cakes were often baked in pie tins.

The dessert became popular well beyond the hotel. In 1996, Massachusetts named Boston cream pie its official state dessert after a campaign that involved schoolchildren and lawmakers. It also inspired the Boston cream doughnut, a favorite in coffee shops across New England.

The roll with a fold

The Parker House roll is a soft, buttery dinner roll made by folding a round of dough in half before baking, which gives it its distinctive pocketbook shape. It was created at the hotel in the 1800s, and recipes for it spread through American cookbooks. Many home bakers still make Parker House rolls for holidays.

Other Boston comfort foods

Winter in Boston calls for hearty food, and the city has a long list of classics:

  • New England clam chowder, the creamy version, served in restaurants all over the city.
  • Boston baked beans, slow-cooked with molasses, a reminder of the city’s trade history and the source of the nickname Beantown.
  • Brown bread, a steamed bread often served with beans.
  • Indian pudding, a cornmeal and molasses dessert with colonial roots.

Making Boston cream pie at home

If you want to bake one on a cold weekend, the basic parts are simple: a light sponge or butter cake, a vanilla pastry cream and a glossy chocolate glaze. Let the cake cool fully before filling, chill the cream well and pour the glaze while it is still warm so it spreads evenly. Many recipes, including versions published by the hotel itself, are easy to find.

Advertisement

Whether you try it in the hotel’s dining room or bake it in your own kitchen, Boston cream pie is a small, sweet piece of city history.

A Baker’s Walkthrough: Boston Cream Pie Step by Step

The dessert has only three parts, but each one rewards a little care. Here is how to approach it on a winter weekend.

1. The cake

  • Bring ingredients to room temperature. Eggs, butter and milk combine more smoothly and trap more air when they are not cold.
  • Do not overmix. Once the flour goes in, mix just until combined. Overmixing develops gluten and makes the cake tough.
  • Bake in a single pan and split it, or bake two thin layers. Splitting a cooled cake with a long serrated knife gives the neatest result.
  • Cool completely before filling. Warm cake will melt the cream and slide apart.

2. The pastry cream

  1. Heat milk with vanilla until steaming.
  2. Whisk egg yolks, sugar and cornstarch in a separate bowl.
  3. Temper the yolks by slowly whisking in a little hot milk, then return everything to the pot.
  4. Cook, whisking constantly, until the mixture thickens and bubbles briefly, which ensures the starch sets.
  5. Strain into a bowl, press plastic wrap directly onto the surface to prevent a skin and chill until firm.

3. The glaze

A simple chocolate glaze is made by pouring hot cream over chopped chocolate and stirring until smooth. Let it cool slightly so it is pourable but not runny, then pour it onto the center of the cake and let it spread toward the edges, nudging it gently with a spatula.

Common mistakes and how to avoid them

  • Runny filling: the cream was not cooked long enough or not chilled fully.
  • Lumpy cream: the eggs scrambled; temper slowly and whisk constantly, and strain if needed.
  • Dull or thick glaze: it cooled too much; warm it gently over low heat.
  • Soggy slices: the cake sat at room temperature too long. Keep it refrigerated, since pastry cream is perishable.

Mastering the Parker House Roll

The roll’s famous fold is easy once you see it done.

  1. Make a soft, enriched dough with butter, milk and a little sugar, and let it rise until doubled.
  2. Roll it out to an even thickness and cut rounds or ovals.
  3. Brush with melted butter, then press a crease across the center of each piece with the back of a knife or a chopstick.
  4. Fold each piece along the crease so the top half overlaps slightly, forming the pocketbook shape.
  5. Let them rise again, close together in the pan, then bake until golden and brush with more butter.

Rolls placed close together rise upward and stay soft on the sides, while rolls spaced apart bake with crisper edges. Both are traditional, so choose the texture you like.

The Hotel as a Living Landmark

The Parker House’s location on School Street puts it right on the Freedom Trail, a short walk from King’s Chapel, Old City Hall and the Old Corner Bookstore. Its long history has produced many stories about famous guests and staff. Some are well documented, while others have grown in the retelling, so it is worth reading the hotel’s own history and other reliable sources if you want to separate fact from legend. Even if you only stop to look at the lobby’s woodwork and old-fashioned elegance, it is a pleasant way to step into nineteenth-century Boston.

Questions Readers Ask

Why is it called a pie if it is a cake?

In the 1800s, cakes were often baked in pie pans, and the words were used more loosely. The name stuck even as the dessert became clearly a cake.

Can I make it ahead?

Yes. Bake the cake and make the pastry cream a day ahead, then assemble and glaze a few hours before serving. Keep it chilled.

Is a Boston cream doughnut the same thing?

It borrows the same idea, a vanilla cream filling with chocolate on top, but in doughnut form.

Latest stories

View all

The George Washington statue in the Boston Public Garden in snow ←
Previous:
Walking the Emerald Necklace in Winter: A Park-by-Park Guide
Museum gallery with large framed oil paintings and a central sculpture →
Next:
Remembering the Blizzard of ’78: The Storm That Stopped Boston