Building the Back Bay: How Boston Filled a Bay and Planned a Neighborhood

The Back Bay was literally a bay until the 1850s. Here is how Boston filled it, laid out Commonwealth Avenue and created its grandest neighborhood.

Lord Howe evacuating Boston in March 1776, 1861 engraving

The name gives it away. The Back Bay was once a tidal bay of the Charles River, a stretch of mud flats and shallow water behind the Boston peninsula. Within a few decades in the second half of the 1800s, it became one of the most carefully planned neighborhoods in America.

From mill dam to mud flat

In the early 1800s, a long dam was built across the bay to power mills, along the line of what is now Beacon Street. The dam cut off the tides, and the basin behind it filled with sewage and stagnant water. By the 1850s, the bay had become a health hazard, and the state and city agreed on a plan to fill it in.

Gravel by rail

Filling began in 1857. Trains carried gravel from pits in Needham, west of the city, running day and night. Crews dumped the fill and leveled it block by block, moving west from the Public Garden. The work continued for decades, gradually creating hundreds of acres of new land.

Advertisement

That is why Back Bay buildings rest on wooden pilings driven down through the fill. Those pilings need to stay wet to avoid rotting, and keeping groundwater at the right level is still a concern for property owners today.

A planned grid

Unlike the winding streets of older Boston, the Back Bay was laid out on a regular grid. The architect Arthur Gilman is credited with much of the plan, which drew on the boulevards of Paris.

  • Commonwealth Avenue has a wide central mall lined with trees and statues, running from the Public Garden west toward Kenmore Square.
  • Cross streets are alphabetical, from Arlington through Berkeley, Clarendon, Dartmouth, Exeter, Fairfield, Gloucester and Hereford.
  • Alleys behind the houses kept service traffic and deliveries off the main streets.

Churches, libraries and towers

As the land was filled, institutions moved in. Copley Square became the neighborhood’s civic heart. Trinity Church, designed by H. H. Richardson and completed in 1877, is often listed among the most important buildings in American architecture. Across the square, the Boston Public Library’s McKim Building opened in the 1890s.

In the twentieth century, the Prudential Tower and the John Hancock Tower, now known by its address at 200 Clarendon Street, added a modern skyline. The Hancock’s mirrored glass reflects Trinity Church, putting old and new Boston in a single view.

Winter in the Back Bay

The Commonwealth Avenue Mall is a lovely winter walk, especially after a snowfall. Start at the Public Garden and head west, reading the statues along the way, including memorials to Alexander Hamilton, the abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison and the historian Samuel Eliot Morison. Newbury Street and Boylston Street are close by for a warm drink.

Advertisement

The Back Bay shows what Boston could do when it set out to build a neighborhood from scratch. Its brownstones and bowfronts look settled and permanent, but they stand on land that, not so long ago, was under water.

Walking West Through Time

Because the Back Bay was filled gradually from east to west, its buildings change in style as you walk away from the Public Garden. A stroll down Commonwealth Avenue or Marlborough Street is a little like reading the late nineteenth century in order.

  • Near Arlington and Berkeley Streets: many of the earliest houses, often in the French Second Empire style, with mansard roofs and uniform rows that follow the Paris-inspired plan.
  • Toward Clarendon and Dartmouth: more variety as Victorian taste shifted, including Gothic and Ruskinian details, colored stone and pointed arches.
  • Exeter through Hereford: later houses in Queen Anne, Richardsonian Romanesque and Colonial Revival styles, with turrets, rough-faced stone, bay windows and more individual designs.

The neighborhood’s height and setback rules helped keep this variety in harmony, so even very different houses form a consistent streetscape.

The Public Garden and the River

The Back Bay’s eastern edge is the Public Garden, established in 1837 and often described as the first public botanical garden in the United States. Its lagoon, footbridge, formal flower beds and the famous duckling statues inspired by Robert McCloskey’s children’s book Make Way for Ducklings make it one of the city’s best-loved spaces.

To the north, the Charles River Esplanade runs along the water, created on filled land after the Charles River was dammed in the early twentieth century and widened in the decades that followed. In winter it is a peaceful place to walk, with views of the frozen edges of the basin and the Cambridge skyline beyond.

Inside a Back Bay House

The Gibson House Museum on Beacon Street preserves a Victorian Back Bay home much as it looked when a family lived there. A visit shows the layout typical of the neighborhood: a kitchen and service rooms on the lower level, formal rooms on the main floors and bedrooms above, with servants’ quarters near the top. It is one of the best ways to understand how these narrow, tall houses actually worked.

A Winter Itinerary

  1. Begin at the Public Garden and cross the footbridge over the lagoon.
  2. Walk the Commonwealth Avenue Mall west, noticing how house styles change block by block.
  3. Turn down to Copley Square to see Trinity Church and the Boston Public Library facing each other.
  4. Warm up inside the library, whose courtyard and reading rooms are open to the public.
  5. End on Newbury Street, where shops and cafes occupy former townhouses.

Questions Readers Ask

Why did Boston fill the Back Bay instead of leaving it as water?

The dammed basin had become polluted and unhealthy, and the city needed room to grow. Filling solved both problems and created valuable land that paid for much of the work.

What happened with the Hancock Tower’s windows?

Soon after construction in the 1970s, some of the tower’s large glass panes cracked and fell, and all of them were eventually replaced. The building went on to become one of the city’s most admired modern towers.

Are Back Bay houses still single-family homes?

Some are, but many were converted into apartments, condominiums, dormitories or offices over the years. A smaller number have been restored as single homes.

Is the Back Bay Fens part of the Back Bay?

The Fens lie just to the west and were part of Olmsted’s Emerald Necklace. They began as a solution to drainage and flooding problems along the Muddy River and the remains of the old marsh.

Latest stories

View all

Historic brick rowhouses on a Beacon Hill street ←
Previous:
Beacon Hill’s Secrets: How a Hilltop Became Boston’s Most Famous Neighborhood
The Paul Revere House in North Square, built around 1680 on the site of a house lost in Boston's Great Fire of 1676 →
Next:
Fenway-Kenmore Beyond the Ballpark: Marshes, Museums and a Famous Sign