Hiring Your First Employee: A Step-by-Step Checklist

Bringing on your first employee involves tax registrations, paperwork and planning. This checklist covers the general steps and where to confirm the details.

A group of people standing next to each other

Hiring your first employee is a milestone. It also turns you into an employer, with obligations that did not exist when it was just you. The steps are manageable if you take them in order. This is a general overview, and requirements vary by state and situation, so confirm the details with official sources and consider talking to an employment attorney or accountant before your new hire’s first day.

Before you post the job

  • Define the role. Write down the responsibilities, schedule, required skills and how you will measure success.
  • Run the numbers. Wages are only part of the cost. Add employer payroll taxes, insurance, any benefits, equipment and the time you will spend training.
  • Confirm it is truly an employee role. Whether someone is an employee or an independent contractor is determined by law, not by preference. Massachusetts applies a strict test, so check state guidance before deciding.
  • Know the wage rules. Federal, state and sometimes local minimum wage and overtime rules apply.

Registrations and accounts

Before you run your first payroll, you will typically need to:

  • Obtain a federal Employer Identification Number from the IRS if you do not already have one.
  • Register with your state tax agency for income tax withholding.
  • Register for state unemployment insurance.
  • Arrange workers’ compensation insurance, which Massachusetts generally requires for employers.
  • Understand any state paid family and medical leave contribution obligations.
  • Choose a payroll system or provider that will calculate withholding and file returns.

First-day paperwork

  • Form I-9 to verify identity and employment eligibility, completed within the required timeframe.
  • Form W-4 for federal withholding, plus any state withholding form.
  • New hire reporting to the state, which employers are required to do within a set period.
  • Required notices. Many states require written notices about pay, leave and other rights.
  • Workplace posters required by federal and state law.

Keep personnel files organized and store sensitive information, such as Social Security numbers and I-9 documents, securely and separately where appropriate.

Advertisement

Set your new hire up to succeed

Compliance gets the hire on payroll. A good start keeps them there. Before day one, prepare the essentials:

  • A written offer letter covering title, pay, schedule and start date.
  • Equipment, accounts and logins ready to go.
  • A short written guide to how the business works, including expectations about hours, communication and time off.
  • A plan for the first week, with real work and time scheduled for questions.
  • A check-in on the calendar at 30, 60 and 90 days.

Where to confirm the details

The IRS covers federal employer obligations at irs.gov. Massachusetts employers can find state requirements for withholding, unemployment insurance, paid leave and workers’ compensation on mass.gov. Because rules and rates change, check the official sources each year, and talk to a professional if your situation includes remote workers in other states, minors or unusual pay arrangements.

Running a Fair, Effective Hiring Process

Getting the paperwork right matters, but so does choosing the right person. A simple, consistent process improves results and reduces legal risk.

  1. Write a clear job posting that describes the work, the schedule, the location and the qualifications that truly matter.
  2. Screen consistently. Decide in advance what you are looking for and apply the same criteria to every applicant.
  3. Use structured interviews. Ask every candidate the same core questions, tied to the work, so you can compare answers fairly.
  4. Include a practical exercise when appropriate, such as a short task that reflects real duties.
  5. Check references with the candidate’s permission, asking about work habits and reliability.
  6. Make a written offer and confirm acceptance before notifying other candidates.

Questions to avoid

Federal and state laws prohibit discrimination based on protected characteristics. Avoid questions about age, religion, national origin, marital status, pregnancy or family plans, disability and similar topics. Massachusetts also restricts certain questions, including asking about salary history and asking about criminal records on an initial written application. Rules are detailed, so check official guidance or ask an employment attorney before you interview.

Setting Up Payroll Without Surprises

  • Choose a pay schedule and confirm it complies with state law, which sets rules about how often employees must be paid.
  • Track hours for employees who are eligible for overtime, even if they are salaried.
  • Know your deposit schedule for withheld taxes, which your payroll provider or accountant can confirm.
  • Review the first few pay stubs carefully to make sure deductions and withholdings are correct.
  • Keep records of hours, pay and deductions for the period required by law.

Common First-Hire Mistakes

  • Misclassifying the worker. Treating an employee as a contractor can lead to back taxes, penalties and wage claims.
  • Paying off the books. Cash payments without withholding create serious legal and tax problems for both parties.
  • Skipping new hire reporting or missing required notices.
  • Not budgeting for the full cost, including taxes, insurance and the owner’s training time.
  • Unclear expectations. Many early hiring problems come from roles that were never clearly defined.

A Simple 90-Day Plan

  • First week: Introductions, tools, training on core tasks and an early win the new employee can complete.
  • First month: Gradually increase responsibility, meet weekly and give feedback early and often.
  • Days 30 to 60: Review progress against the goals you set, adjust training and ask the employee what would help.
  • Days 60 to 90: Discuss performance, longer-term goals and any changes to the role.

Questions Readers Ask

Should I use a payroll provider?

Many small employers do, because providers calculate withholding, file returns and keep records. Compare options and confirm what is included.

Advertisement

Do I need an employee handbook?

With one employee, a short written guide may be enough. As you grow, a handbook reviewed by an employment attorney can clarify policies and help meet notice requirements.

Can I hire a family member?

Yes, but the same employment and tax rules generally apply, with some special cases. Ask your accountant how it works for your situation.

What if my first hire is part-time?

Part-time employees are still employees. Withholding, unemployment insurance, workers’ compensation, required notices and many leave rules generally apply regardless of hours, though some benefits and obligations depend on hours worked or the size of your workforce. Confirm which rules apply before the first paycheck.

How do I handle a remote employee in another state?

An employee working from another state may make you subject to that state’s payroll tax, unemployment and employment laws. Registration requirements can apply even for a single worker, so talk with your accountant or payroll provider before the hire starts.

When should I write job descriptions and policies?

Before you post the job. A written description guides your interviews, sets expectations for the employee and becomes the starting point for performance conversations and future hires.

Latest stories

View all

Person writing on white paper ←
Previous:
Three Ways to Price a Service, and How to Choose Among Them
Massachusetts State House with its golden dome under a blue sky →
Next:
Where Massachusetts Small Businesses Can Find Official Help