Holiday-Season Scams: Protecting a Small Team From Fraud and Phishing

Busy seasons create openings for fraud. Learn the scams that commonly target businesses at year-end and the simple controls that help a small team stay safe.

A person holding a black smartphone

The months leading up to the holidays are busy for nearly every business. Orders increase, staff take time off, deliveries pile up and everyone is moving quickly. Scammers know this. Fraud attempts that might be spotted on a quiet day in March can slip through on a hectic afternoon in December. A few clear controls, agreed on in October, help a small team stay alert when it matters most.

Scams to watch for

  • Fake delivery notices. Emails and texts claiming a package could not be delivered, with a link to reschedule or pay a fee.
  • Gift card requests. A message that appears to come from the owner or a manager asking an employee to buy gift cards for clients or staff and send the codes.
  • Vendor payment changes. An email, seemingly from a supplier, announcing new bank account details just before a large payment.
  • Fake invoices. Bills for products or services never ordered, timed to blend in with year-end paperwork.
  • Charity scams. Requests for donations from organizations that sound legitimate but are not.
  • Fraudulent orders. For retailers, orders placed with stolen cards, often for high-value items with rush shipping.

Controls that work

Simple, consistent rules protect better than relying on everyone to spot every trick:

  • Require verification by phone, using a known number, for any change to payment instructions.
  • Require a second person to approve payments above a set amount.
  • Make it a firm policy that the business never asks employees to buy gift cards by email or text.
  • Only pay invoices that match a purchase order or known agreement.
  • Check delivery and account status by going directly to the carrier’s or vendor’s website, not through links in messages.
  • Research charities before giving through official resources.

Prepare for staff absences

Holiday time off can leave unfamiliar people covering tasks like paying bills or handling customer accounts. Fraudsters sometimes exploit that confusion. Before the season starts, document who covers what, make sure substitutes know the verification rules and avoid sharing passwords as a workaround. Use the access controls in your systems to grant temporary permissions instead.

Advertisement

Keep the team informed

A short reminder at a staff meeting in October or November is often enough to raise awareness. Share examples of real suspicious messages the business has received. Encourage people to pause and ask when something feels off, and thank them when they do. Make reporting easy and free of blame.

If something goes wrong

Act quickly. If money was sent, contact your bank immediately, since speed can sometimes make a difference. Change any compromised passwords and check that multi-factor authentication is enabled. Report fraud to the Federal Trade Commission at reportfraud.ftc.gov and, for internet-enabled crimes, to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov. Consider consulting an attorney or IT security professional if sensitive data or significant funds are involved.

Putting It Into Practice: A Holiday Fraud Drill

Rules work best when people have practiced them. A short exercise in October or early November can turn a written policy into a reflex. Here is a simple drill a small team can run in about thirty minutes.

  1. Gather a few examples. Collect suspicious messages the business has actually received, with any sensitive details removed, plus one or two legitimate messages for contrast.
  2. Show them one at a time. Ask the team whether each is genuine and what clues they notice: urgency, unusual requests, mismatched sender addresses or links that do not match the company named.
  3. Walk through the response. For each suspicious example, ask what the right next step would be. Who do you call? Which number do you use? Who needs to know?
  4. Review the rules. Restate the verification and approval policies, and confirm everyone knows who is covering which tasks during the holidays.
  5. Make reporting easy. Agree on one simple way to flag a suspicious message, such as forwarding it to a designated person.

Warning Signs in Any Message

Scams change their details constantly, but most share a few telltale features. Encourage the team to pause when a message:

  • Creates urgency, such as a deadline measured in hours or a threat that an account will be closed.
  • Asks for secrecy, such as “do not mention this to anyone until it is done.”
  • Requests an unusual form of payment, like gift cards, wire transfers to a new account or cryptocurrency.
  • Comes from an address or phone number that is slightly different from the usual one.
  • Contains links or attachments you were not expecting.
  • Asks you to bypass a normal approval step “just this once.”

Any one of these is a reason to slow down. Two or more together are a strong reason to stop and verify.

Advertisement

Protecting Customers Too

Holiday scams do not only target businesses. Criminals sometimes impersonate legitimate companies to defraud their customers. A business can help protect the people it serves by:

  • Telling customers clearly how the business will and will not contact them, for example that it will never ask for a password or full card number by email.
  • Using consistent sender names and addresses for order confirmations and shipping updates.
  • Posting a short notice on the website if a scam using the business’s name is circulating.
  • Giving customers an easy way to check whether a message really came from the business.

Questions Small Teams Ask About Holiday Fraud

What if a message really does come from the owner?

Then a quick call to confirm costs only a minute. Owners should actively encourage verification so employees never feel awkward about it.

Should we block all links in email?

That is rarely practical for a working business. A better habit is to navigate to important sites directly by typing the address or using a saved bookmark, especially for payments and account changes.

How quickly should we act if we suspect fraud?

Immediately. The sooner a bank, payment provider or account administrator is notified, the more options there may be to limit the damage.

Is this only a holiday problem?

No. Fraud happens all year, but busy seasons and staff absences make it easier for attempts to slip through. The habits built for the holidays are worth keeping year-round. Consider repeating the drill each spring as well, using any new examples the team has collected in the meantime, so the rules stay fresh for new hires and long-time staff alike.

Latest stories

View all

A crowd gathered in front of an outdoor stage at dusk, watching a concert ←
Previous:
Swiftie Trivia Is Coming to Boston Made
AI-generated illustration of a white shuttle bus at a stop on a tree-lined Boston street with brick triple-deckers in autumn →
Next:
Five Free Bus Lines Are Coming. Here Is What Boston Still Has to Get Right