Opinion: Who Owns the Patriots’ Slide: Vrabel, the Injuries, or the Roster?

From 5-3 to .500 with the quarterback hurt. Three explanations for the Patriots’ slide, three different fixes, and one question for New England: whose fault is it?

An empty green turf football field ringed by trees

Three weeks ago the New England Patriots were 5-3 and climbing national power rankings. They come out of their bye at .500, with their quarterback hurt and a fan base arguing about whose fault it is. That argument is worth having out loud, because the three usual answers point to three very different fixes.

How it unraveled

The slide has been quick. NBC Sports Boston’s running coverage tracks it: a Thursday night loss to the Bears, a 45-27 home loss to Green Bay that the outlet called one of the most embarrassing defeats Gillette Stadium has seen, and then a loss to the Lions in Munich in which Drake Maye was injured. The team went into its bye still waiting on official word about his status, and its Week 12 date with the Chargers was flexed out of Sunday Night Football. The league does not move a game it thinks people want to watch.

The case against Mike Vrabel

Local sports radio has spent the bye asking how much of this lands on the head coach, and the argument is simple. The Green Bay game was not close, it was at home, and it came with a healthy quarterback. Preparation, discipline and in-game adjustments are the coach’s department. If the message is not landing in the locker room, the person delivering it has to answer for that.

Advertisement

The case for bad luck

The counterargument is the injury report. NBC Sports Boston has pointed out that the 2025 team enjoyed unusually good health and the 2026 team has had the opposite, and losing a franchise quarterback changes every other evaluation. A coach cannot scheme around a depth chart that keeps getting shorter. On this reading, patience is the fix and panic is the mistake.

The case that the roster was never this good

The least comfortable answer is that 5-3 flattered a team with real holes, and that a soft early schedule hid them. If that is right, neither a healthy Maye nor a sharper game plan closes the gap, and the honest conversation is about the offseason.

What settles it

The schedule will. After the Chargers come Buffalo, Minnesota on a Thursday, a Monday night trip to Kansas City, and Denver. A well-coached team with a thin roster stays competitive in games like those. A team with a coaching problem gets run out of the building again.

Your call

Who owns the slide: the coach, the injuries, or the roster? Pick one and defend it in the comments. “All three” is not allowed.

Game facts and schedule details are from NBC Sports Boston’s reporting through Nov. 17, 2026. This is an opinion piece.

Advertisement

Latest stories

View all
Editorial · Nov 21, 2026Opinion: The Hardest Gig in Boston Is the One Nobody Bought a Ticket ForBoston celebrates its concert halls. Its real house band is the working musician in the corner of the room, and Bill McGoldrick’s acoustic duo…Read story
A large illuminated Christmas tree glowing in a misty town square at night as a couple walks past ←
Previous:
Why a Nova Scotia Tree Lights Boston Common Every Holiday Season