The Boston Massacre: Five Deaths That Changed America
On March 5, 1770, a confrontation on King Street ended in gunfire and became one of the Revolution’s defining propaganda battles.
31 Days of Boston — Day 14
On March 5, 1770, a confrontation on King Street ended in gunfire and became one of the Revolution’s defining propaganda battles.
Boston was cold on the night of March 5, 1770. Tension between townspeople and British troops had been building for months. Near the Custom House on King Street, an argument grew into a crowd. Within minutes, shots would echo off the buildings — and Boston would begin a struggle over the meaning of those shots that has never fully ended.
The Night on King Street
King Street, today’s State Street, was the heart of colonial Boston. The Town House — now the Old State House — stood at its head, and the street ran down toward Long Wharf and the harbor. The Custom House, where royal revenue was collected and stored, stood along it. A lone British sentry was posted there that night.
The trouble began with a dispute between the sentry and a young apprentice. Word spread. Bells rang, which in colonial Boston often meant fire, drawing more people into the streets. A crowd gathered around the sentry, who called for help. Captain Thomas Preston arrived with a small detachment of soldiers.
Insults flew. Objects were thrown. Soldiers formed with loaded muskets. Then shots rang out.
No one knows with certainty whether Preston ordered his men to fire. The scene was dark, loud, and chaotic, with snow and ice on the ground and voices shouting “fire” in many different senses. Witnesses later gave conflicting accounts.
The Five Who Died
Five civilians ultimately died from the confrontation, including Crispus Attucks. Attucks, a man of African and Native American descent who worked as a sailor, is often remembered as the first to fall. The others killed were Samuel Gray, a ropewalk worker; James Caldwell, a sailor; Samuel Maverick, a young apprentice; and Patrick Carr, who died days later of his wounds. Others were wounded.
The victims were given a massive public funeral and buried together in the Granary Burying Ground, where their grave can still be visited. Attucks in particular became a powerful symbol in later generations, especially for Black Americans and abolitionists who pointed to his sacrifice as evidence that the cause of liberty belonged to all.
The Battle Over the Story
The killings immediately became a political event. Patriot leaders understood that the story of the shooting could be as powerful as the shooting itself. Paul Revere’s famous engraving presented an orderly British line firing into helpless colonists, an image more useful as propaganda than as a neutral reconstruction.
Revere’s print, closely based on a design by artist Henry Pelham, showed soldiers firing in a neat line at the command of an officer with raised sword, and a calm, well-dressed crowd. It even labeled the Custom House “Butcher’s Hall.” The image circulated widely and shaped how Americans imagined the event for generations. The town also published its own account, gathering testimony that blamed the soldiers. The name itself — “massacre” — was an argument.
Officials and the soldiers’ defenders told a different story: of a hostile crowd, a frightened detachment, and men acting in self-defense against clubs, ice, and stones. Both sides sent their versions to London.
Law in the Middle of Fury
Yet Boston also produced another remarkable chapter. John Adams participated in the defense of the British soldiers, insisting that law mattered even amid political fury. Several soldiers were acquitted; two were convicted of manslaughter.
Adams, then a young lawyer, took the case alongside Josiah Quincy Jr. and others, knowing it could damage his reputation. Preston was tried separately and acquitted. In the soldiers’ trial, the defense argued that the men had been threatened by a dangerous crowd. Six were acquitted. The two convicted of manslaughter avoided death by claiming an old legal privilege called “benefit of clergy,” and were branded on the thumb instead.
The trials showed that even in a town at the center of resistance, a jury could weigh evidence and reach a verdict that many in the community did not want. Adams later regarded his role in the defense as one of the most important services of his life.
Why the Massacre Mattered
The Massacre mattered because it fused memory, media, law, and politics. Boston did not simply experience the event. Boston fought over what the event meant—and that fight helped move a population toward revolution.
For years afterward, Bostonians marked the anniversary each March 5 with public orations recalling the dangers of standing armies. The shooting became part of a larger narrative of British oppression. At the same time, the trials offered a counter-story about fairness and the rule of law. Both stories were true in their way, and both became part of Boston’s identity.
Visiting the Site This Week
- Find the marker. A circle of cobblestones in the street near the Old State House marks the area of the shooting.
- Visit the Granary Burying Ground. The victims’ shared grave lies near those of other revolutionary figures.
- Compare the images. Look at Revere’s engraving and ask what it shows, what it leaves out, and why.
- Read the trial record. Testimony from the trials offers a far more complicated picture than the famous print.
Research & Further Reading
For deeper research, consult authoritative collections including the Massachusetts Historical Society, Boston Public Library, National Park Service, Library of Congress, Massachusetts Archives, and relevant museum and university collections. Readers should verify contested details against primary and scholarly sources.
Boston Made is an independent editorial and archival platform. Historical stories are intended to encourage further exploration of primary sources, museums, libraries, and scholarly research.











