The Boston Smallpox Wars: The Experiment That Divided a City

During Boston’s 1721 smallpox epidemic, Cotton Mather and Zabdiel Boylston backed inoculation—and ignited a fierce public battle.

Small antique medicine bottles on a windowsill

31 Days of Boston — Day 7

During Boston’s 1721 smallpox epidemic, Cotton Mather and Zabdiel Boylston backed inoculation—and ignited a fierce public battle.

In 1721, smallpox struck Boston with terrifying force. The disease was familiar, deadly, and deeply feared. Into that crisis came a controversial idea: deliberately expose a healthy person to material from a smallpox case in hopes of producing a milder infection and future immunity. What followed was one of the most bitter public arguments in colonial American history — and one of the earliest in which numbers, not just authority, were used to settle a medical question.

Advertisement

A City Under Siege by Disease

Smallpox was one of the most feared diseases of the eighteenth century. It spread from person to person, caused high fever and a painful rash of pustules, and killed a substantial share of those it infected. Survivors were often scarred for life, and some were blinded. Those who recovered, however, did not catch it again — a fact that people had observed for centuries.

Boston had suffered smallpox outbreaks before, and because the disease had been absent for some years, many younger residents had never been exposed. In the spring of 1721, smallpox arrived aboard a ship from the Caribbean. Despite efforts to isolate the sick, it spread through the crowded town. By summer, Boston faced a full epidemic, and many families fled to the countryside.

Where the Idea Came From

Cotton Mather became a prominent advocate after learning about inoculation practices, including knowledge communicated by Onesimus, an enslaved African man in Mather’s household. Physician Zabdiel Boylston put the method into practice.

Onesimus described to Mather how, in Africa, people had been deliberately given a mild case of smallpox to protect them from the disease. Mather, a minister with wide scientific interests, had also read reports circulating through learned societies in London describing similar practices in the Ottoman world. He became convinced the method could save lives.

The role of Onesimus deserves emphasis. Knowledge that would shape public health in Boston came from an enslaved man whose expertise was recorded mainly because a prominent minister wrote about it. His story is a reminder that the history of science includes contributors whose names were rarely credited at the time.

Advertisement

Mather urged Boston’s physicians to try inoculation. Most refused. Zabdiel Boylston, a physician willing to take the risk, inoculated his own young son and two enslaved members of his household in June 1721. When they recovered, he continued, eventually inoculating hundreds of people over the course of the epidemic.

How Inoculation Worked

The method, often called variolation, involved making a small cut in a healthy person’s skin and introducing material taken from a smallpox sore. The result was usually a milder illness than smallpox caught in the ordinary way, followed by lifelong immunity. It was not risk-free: some inoculated people became seriously ill or died, and inoculated patients could spread smallpox to others while they were sick.

That is very different from vaccination, which came later in the century, when Edward Jenner showed that material from cowpox could protect against smallpox without exposing people to smallpox itself. Modern vaccines are different again. The 1721 debate was about an older and riskier technique, which helps explain why reasonable people at the time disagreed so sharply. (This is history, not medical guidance; questions about your own health and vaccines belong with your doctor.)

A Town Divided

Boston exploded into argument. Critics considered inoculation dangerous, reckless, even morally suspect. Supporters believed the evidence showed it could save lives. The dispute spilled into newspapers and public attacks.

Many of the town’s physicians opposed the practice, arguing that it spread infection and lacked proof. Some critics objected on religious grounds, believing it presumptuous to deliberately give someone a disease. Others resented that ministers were weighing in on medicine. Boylston faced fierce hostility, and Mather’s house was attacked with an explosive device thrown through a window; it failed to go off.

The newspapers became a battlefield. The New-England Courant, a new paper published by James Franklin, took a strong stand against inoculation and against the town’s ministerial establishment. Franklin’s younger brother, a teenage apprentice named Benjamin, was learning the printing trade in that shop at the time.

The Numbers That Changed the Argument

When the epidemic subsided, supporters of inoculation did something unusual: they counted. Boylston and others compiled records comparing people who caught smallpox naturally with those who had been inoculated. Their tallies indicated that inoculated patients died at a far lower rate — roughly 2 percent, compared with about 14 percent among those infected the ordinary way. Boylston later published his findings, and his work drew attention in London.

The episode feels strikingly modern because it combined epidemic fear, emerging statistics, medical uncertainty, media conflict, and distrust of authority. Boston became an early American arena for debating how evidence should guide public health. The controversy did not settle every question, but it helped establish a tradition of testing ideas against outcomes.

What the Smallpox Wars Teach Us

The 1721 controversy offers lessons that apply far beyond medicine:

  • Evidence persuades slowly. Data mattered, but it took time, and fear often moved faster than facts.
  • Knowledge comes from unexpected places. A crucial insight came from an enslaved man, not from the town’s medical establishment.
  • Media amplifies conflict. A new newspaper found an audience by challenging authority — a pattern that would repeat throughout Boston history.
  • Trust is part of public health. Who delivered the message mattered as much as the message itself.

This week, consider reading about Onesimus and the 1721 epidemic in the collections of the Massachusetts Historical Society, or walking past the sites of the old town center and imagining a city where everyone was arguing about the same question.

Research & Further Reading

For deeper research, consult authoritative collections including the Massachusetts Historical Society, Boston Public Library, National Park Service, Library of Congress, Massachusetts Archives, and relevant museum and university collections. Readers should verify contested details against primary and scholarly sources.

Boston Made is an independent editorial and archival platform. Historical stories are intended to encourage further exploration of primary sources, museums, libraries, and scholarly research.

Latest stories

View all

A South East View of the Great Town of Boston in New England in America, with ships in the harbor, after William Burgis ←
Previous:
Pirates, Privateers & the Dangerous Waters of Colonial Boston
Interior of a grand church with stained glass windows →
Next:
The Great Awakening: When Religion Shook Boston