What Investors Look For Before Investing

Over the years I have sat on both sides of the table — asking for support for my own ventures and helping other founders get ready to ask for theirs. The same lessons come up again and again.

What Investors Look For Before Investing — Boston Made Archive, Investor Relations

Over the years I have sat on both sides of the table — asking for support for my own ventures and helping other founders get ready to ask for theirs. The same lessons come up again and again. Investors are not looking for perfection. They are looking for evidence: evidence that the problem is real, that the team can solve it and that the business can grow into something worth far more than it costs to build.

Here is what that evidence usually looks like.

1. A real problem and a clear customer

The strongest companies start with a specific person who has a specific, painful problem. Investors want to know exactly who your customer is, how they solve the problem today and why your way is meaningfully better. “Everyone” is not a customer. A clear, well-understood customer is.

Advertisement

2. The team

Early on, investors are often betting on people more than products. They look for founders who know their market deeply, who can recruit talented people, who learn quickly from mistakes and who will keep going when things get hard. Honesty about what the team does not yet know is a strength, not a weakness.

3. Traction

Nothing persuades like proof. Traction can take many forms: paying customers, growing revenue, repeat usage, a waiting list, signed letters of intent or strong engagement in a pilot. Whatever stage you are at, show the trend, not just a single number.

4. A business model that makes sense

Investors want to understand how money flows. How do you charge? What does it cost to win a customer, and how much is that customer worth over time? Can margins improve as you grow? A simple, honest model beats an elaborate spreadsheet built on hopeful assumptions.

5. Market size and timing

A great business in a tiny market can only grow so far. Investors want to see that the opportunity is large enough to matter and that the timing is right — that something in technology, regulation or customer behavior has changed to make your solution possible or necessary now.

6. A defensible position

What stops a larger competitor from copying you? Defensibility can come from intellectual property, proprietary data, a trusted brand, network effects, exclusive partnerships or simply a head start executed exceptionally well.

Advertisement

7. Clean house

Before any serious investment, there will be due diligence. Investors will want to see that the company is properly formed, that ownership is clearly documented, that intellectual property belongs to the company, that contracts are in order and that the books are accurate. Messy records can slow or even end an otherwise promising conversation.

8. A clear plan for the money

Finally, investors want to know what their capital will accomplish. How much are you raising, how long will it last and what milestones will it reach? The best answer connects the money directly to the next stage of proof.

A founder’s checklist

  • Can I describe my customer and their problem in two sentences?
  • Do I have evidence — not just belief — that customers want this?
  • Are my company records, ownership and contracts organized?
  • Do I know my key numbers by heart?
  • Can I explain exactly what the next round of capital will achieve?

At Boston Made, these are the same questions we ask ourselves as we build each of our companies. Getting ready for investment is really just getting ready to run a better business. Do that work well, and the right partners tend to find you.

This letter is general information for entrepreneurs and is not investment, legal or tax advice, nor an offer or solicitation regarding any security.

Putting It Into Practice: Preparing Your Data Room

Several of the points above come together when an investor asks for documents. A data room is simply an organized, secure folder of the materials a serious investor will want to review. Building one before anyone asks is one of the best signals of a well-run company. A simple structure might look like this:

  1. Corporate formation. Certificate of incorporation or organization, bylaws or operating agreement, and evidence of good standing.
  2. Ownership. A current capitalization table and copies of every equity grant, convertible note or similar instrument.
  3. Governance. Board or owner minutes and written consents.
  4. Financials. Historical statements, the current budget, and the model behind your projections, with assumptions explained.
  5. Customers and contracts. Material customer, supplier and partner agreements, plus a summary of key terms.
  6. Intellectual property. A list of registrations, domains and key software, along with signed assignment agreements.
  7. People. An organization chart, standard employment and contractor agreements, and key policies.

Keep a simple index at the top and update it whenever something changes. A tidy data room shortens diligence and tells investors a great deal about how you run the business.

Mistakes That Cost Founders Credibility

  • Inflating the numbers. Counting free users as customers or annualizing one strong month as yearly revenue tends to be discovered quickly, and it rarely survives diligence.
  • Not knowing the basics. Hesitating over cash on hand, monthly spend or customer acquisition cost suggests a founder who is not close to the business.
  • Dismissing competitors. Saying there is no competition usually signals a lack of research. Every customer solves the problem somehow today.
  • Raising without a plan. Asking for money without tying it to specific milestones makes it hard for investors to judge what success looks like.
  • Treating investors as interchangeable. The right partner brings experience, relationships and patience. Taking money from someone whose expectations do not match yours creates problems that last for years.

Questions to Ask Investors in Return

Due diligence runs both ways. A founder choosing an investor is entering a long relationship and deserves to understand it. Consider asking:

  • How do you typically support companies after investing?
  • What happens when a company you back misses its plan?
  • How long do you usually expect to hold an investment?
  • Would you be comfortable introducing me to founders you have backed, including ones whose companies struggled?
  • What decisions would you expect to have a say in?

Listen closely to how an investor talks about past companies that did not work out. Someone who speaks respectfully about a struggling founder is likely to treat you the same way when your own plan hits a rough patch.

The answers will tell you as much about fit as any term sheet. As with the letter above, treat this as general information and work with qualified legal, tax and financial professionals before accepting any investment.

Latest stories

View all

IPO vs. Direct Listing vs. Reverse Merger — Boston Made Archive, Going Public ←
Previous:
IPO vs. Direct Listing vs. Reverse Merger
Creating an Investor Relations Website — Boston Made Archive, Investor Relations →
Next:
Creating an Investor Relations Website